Apache Kafka vs. ESB / ETL / MQ

Read why enterprises leverage the open source ecosystem of Apache Kafka for successful integration of different legacy and modern applications instead of ESB, ETL or MQ.

Apache Kafka and Enterprise Service Bus (ESB) are complementary, not competitive!

Apache Kafka is much more than messaging in the meantime. It evolved to a streaming platform including Kafka Connect, Kafka Streams, KSQL and many other open source components. Kafka leverages events as a core principle. You think in data flows of events and process the data while it is in motion. Many concepts, such as event sourcing, or design patterns such as Enterprise Integration Patterns (EIPs), are based on event-driven architecture.

Kafka is unique because it combines messaging, storage, and processing of events all in one platform. It does this in a distributed architecture using a distributed commit log and topics divided into multiple partitions.

ETL and ESB have excellent tooling, including graphical mappings for doing complex integration with legacy systems and technologies such as SOAP, EDIFACT, SAP BAPI, COBOL, etc. (Trust me, you don’t want to write the code for this.)

Therefore, existing MQ and ESB solutions, which already integrate with your legacy world, are not competitive to Apache Kafka. Rather, they are complementary!

Read more details about this question in my Confluent blog post:

Apache Kafka® vs. Enterprise Service Bus (EBS) | Confluent

As always, I appreciate any feedback, comments or criticism.

Dont‘ miss my next post. Subscribe!

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.
If you have issues with the registration, please try a private browser tab / incognito mode. If it doesn't help, write me: kontakt@kai-waehner.de

2 comments
  1. Hello Kai,

    Thanks for this post. I am still slightly confused (not because of your article though) why Kafka isn’t an “Enhanced/Improved ESB” vs. Traditional ESB? I suppose you could use Kafka as ESB, BUT it’s an anti-pattern and Kafka is meant to decentralise ESB-like architecture..

Leave a Reply
You May Also Like
How to do Error Handling in Data Streaming
Read More

Error Handling via Dead Letter Queue in Apache Kafka

Recognizing and handling errors is essential for any reliable data streaming pipeline. This blog post explores best practices for implementing error handling using a Dead Letter Queue in Apache Kafka infrastructure. The options include a custom implementation, Kafka Streams, Kafka Connect, the Spring framework, and the Parallel Consumer. Real-world case studies show how Uber, CrowdStrike, Santander Bank, and Robinhood build reliable real-time error handling at an extreme scale.
Read More